Choose the Assessment for the Objective

Choose the Assessment for the Objective

This guide is designed to help faculty intentionally select Assignments, Tests, or Discussions in Blackboard Ultra based on what they want students to demonstrate, and set up the assessment so it supports clear expectations and measurable outcomes.

Assignments, Tests, and Discussions are designed to capture different kinds of evidence—so the best tool depends on what you want students to show

Watch the recorded GOLD Power Session on Assessment Alignment to learn how assignments, tests, and discussions are designed to measure different kinds of learning.

Three Types of Ultra Assessments:

Assignments (best when students must produce something):

  • Strong fit for: products, performances, projects, written work, applied tasks, multi-step work.
  • Reinforce quality and consistency with rubrics and feedback.

Tests (best when students must recognize/recall/apply under constraints):

  • Strong fit for: checks for understanding, objective measures, item-based evaluation.

Discussions (best when students must explain, justify, interact, or reflect):

  • Strong fit for: reasoning, argumentation, peer interaction, reflection, perspective-taking.

How Learning Objectives Drive Assessment Choice

  • The verb in a learning objective describes what students must do
  • That verb tells you what evidence of learning you need to see
  • The assessment type is chosen based on which tool best captures that evidence
      1. “Calculate dosage accurately using the provided formula and show your work.”
        • Evidence: Produce work + show reasoning
        • Best tool: Assignment
      2. “Identify key terms and concepts from Module 2 readings.”
        • Evidence: Recognition/recall evidence
        • Best tool: Test
      3. “Defend a position using course concepts and respond constructively to peers.”
        • Evidence: Argumentation + interaction evidence
        • Best tool: Discussion

Decision Guide

Use an Assignment when students need to…

  • Create, write, design, or build something
  • Solve a problem and show their work
  • Apply skills or knowledge to a real‑world task
  • Submit a file, project, or performance

Best for measuring:

  • Application
  • Skill development
  • Analysis and synthesis

Ultra tips:

  • Use rubrics for clear expectations and consistent grading
  • Provide targeted feedback to support learning

Use a Test when students need to…

  • Identify, recall, or recognize key information
  • Demonstrate understanding of concepts or terminology
  • Apply knowledge to structured questions

Best for measuring:

  • Knowledge and comprehension
  • Content coverage
  • Baseline understanding

Ultra tips:

  • Use tests for checks for understanding, not complex reasoning
  • Pair with another tool if deeper learning is required

Use a Discussion when students need to…

  • Explain their thinking or justify decisions
  • Reflect on learning or experiences
  • Interact with peers and respond to different perspectives
  • Analyze, debate, or support an argument

Best for measuring:

  • Reasoning
  • Communication
  • Engagement and interaction

Ultra tips:

  • Align prompts closely to outcomes
  • Use a discussion rubric to clarify expectations

When Objectives Are Complex

Some learning objectives can’t be measured with a single assessment. Using multiple assessments allows instructors to gather a more complete picture of what students know and can do.

Example approach:

  • Test → Check foundational knowledge
  • Assignment or Discussion → Measure application or reasoning